Published 2026-11-06 · Kama'aina Locksmith
Quick Answer
Rekeying locks changes the pins inside your existing hardware so old keys stop working; replacing locks swaps the whole unit. On Oahu, rekey when the lock is sound and you only need new keys, and replace when salt air, wear or a security upgrade calls for new hardware. Kama'aina Locksmith does both; call (808) 202-3257 for an upfront quote.
Key Takeaways
- Rekeying keeps your lock and changes which key opens it; replacing installs new hardware and new keys.
- Rekey after a move, a lost key or a tenant change when the lock still turns smoothly and the hardware is in good shape.
- Replace when the cylinder is corroded, the bolt binds, the lock is a low grade, or you want a keypad or smart lock.
- Mixed brands on one house can often be rekeyed to a single key, but some combinations need a cylinder swap first.
- Kama'aina Locksmith quotes either job upfront by phone, with no after-hours surcharge, and asks for ID that matches the address.
What is the difference between rekeying and replacing a lock?
Rekeying changes the inside of the lock; replacing changes the whole lock. In a rekey, the locksmith removes the cylinder, swaps the small pins inside to match a new key, and puts the same lock back on the door. The old keys no longer work, and the hardware you see from the street looks exactly the same.
Replacing means taking the old lock off and installing a new deadbolt, knob, lever or smart lock in its place. You get new keys because the lock is new, and you also get whatever the new hardware brings: a better grade, a fresh finish, a keypad or a longer bolt.
Both jobs end with old keys that no longer open your door. The question is whether the lock itself is worth keeping, and on Oahu that depends on more than age.
When is rekeying enough?
Rekeying is enough when the lock works well and the only problem is who has a key. That covers most of the calls we take across Honolulu:
- You just bought or rented a home in Manoa, Kaimuki or Pearl City and have no idea how many copies the last owner handed out.
- A key was lost at the beach, left in a rental car or never returned by a contractor or cleaner.
- A tenant moved out of a unit in Waikiki or Ala Moana and the next one moves in this week.
- A PCS move into housing near Schofield Barracks or Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam, where the housing office allows a rekey and expects the original hardware to stay.
- Your doors use 3 different keys and you want one key for all of them.
In each case the metal is fine and the keys are the issue, so a lock rekeying visit solves it without touching the finish or the door. Most residential locks can be rekeyed in place.
When should you replace the lock instead?
Replace the lock when the hardware itself is the weak point. Rekeying a lock that binds, wobbles or has green crust on the cylinder only gives you a new key for a failing lock. Signs that point to replacement:
- The key sticks or needs jiggling, or the bolt drags when the door is open, which means wear or corrosion inside.
- The lock is a builder-grade knob with no deadbolt, or a deadbolt with a short throw and a thin strike plate.
- You want a keypad, Wi-Fi or retrofit smart lock, which is a new unit by definition.
- The lock was forced, drilled or kicked in a break-in, even if it still turns.
- The finish has pitted through from salt air and the hardware looks its age.
Sometimes the middle path is a cylinder replacement: the body of the lock stays, and only the keyed cylinder is swapped for a new one. That fixes a corroded or worn cylinder without a new hole in the door, and it works well on commercial-style levers and some mortise locks.
Side by side: rekeying and replacing compared
Use this table to see which option matches the problem you are solving.
| Question | Rekey | Replace |
|---|---|---|
| Does the look of the door change | No | Yes, new hardware and finish |
| Do old keys stop working | Yes | Yes |
| Fixes a sticking or corroded cylinder | No | Yes |
| Upgrades the grade or bolt length | No | Yes |
| Lets you add a keypad or smart lock | No | Yes |
| One key for every door | Yes, if the cylinders are compatible | Yes, when the new locks match |
| Works in a rental or military housing without approval | Usually, ask first | Often needs permission |
| Parts needed from the mainland | Rarely | Sometimes, for specific models |
| Cost | Quoted upfront by phone, before we start | Quoted upfront by phone, before we start |
Neither option is the right answer for every door. Many Honolulu homes end up with a mix: a rekey on the doors that are sound and a replacement on the one that faces the weather.
How does salt air change the decision on Oahu?
Salt air tips the balance toward replacement sooner than it would on the mainland. Along the coast in Hawaii Kai, Kailua, Ewa Beach and Waianae, a steady trade wind carries salt onto every exposed lock. It eats the plating first, then the springs and pins inside the cylinder. A lock that looks fine from the street may be seizing inside.
Here is how we judge it on a visit. If the key turns smoothly and the cylinder comes out clean, a rekey is a safe choice and the lock has years left. If the pins are pitted or the plug is stiff, rekeying it would be money spent on hardware that is already failing, and we will say so.
Single-wall homes add another factor. Many have older doors with worn bores, and a new lock may need a longer bolt or a reinforced strike to sit right. Humidity also matters for anything electronic, so a smart lock on an exposed door should sit under a lanai roof or be a model built for the weather.
What about condos, rentals and military housing?
In a condo, a rental or on base, the owner of the hardware decides, so ask before either job. We do not interpret house rules or leases, and neither should a lock installer who wants the sale.
In some Honolulu high-rises, the AOAO requires that the building key still works in your unit door for emergencies, and some buildings want a uniform look in the hallway. A rekey that keeps the building key working is usually straightforward; a visible replacement may need written approval. Ask your resident manager both questions.
Renters should ask the landlord or property manager in writing. Many allow a rekey at the tenant's expense as long as the landlord receives a key. Military families at Schofield Barracks, Fort Shafter and Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam should check with the housing office first and keep any original parts for move-out inspection.
Which should you choose?
Choose with these if-then rules, which settle most Oahu calls in one conversation:
- If the lock turns smoothly and your only worry is who has a key, rekey it.
- If the key sticks, the bolt drags or you see corrosion on the cylinder, replace the lock or at least the cylinder.
- If you want a keypad or smart lock, you are replacing by definition, so put the new unit on the door you use most and rekey the others to match.
- If you live near the shoreline and the lock is more than a few years old, lean toward a replacement in a corrosion-resistant finish; a rekey only postpones the next call.
- If you rent, live in a condo or in military housing, choose whichever option your landlord, AOAO or housing office approves, and get that approval in writing.
When you are unsure, describe the lock and the problem on the phone. We will tell you which job fits before anyone drives out, and we see every option on our services page.
Related guide: home security checklist for Oahu.
What does each option cost, and what should you have ready?
Both jobs are quoted upfront by phone, before we start, and there is no after-hours surcharge for evenings or weekends. The quote depends on how many locks you have, whether they can be keyed to one key, and the hardware you choose if you replace. Payment is made after the work is done.
Have these ready when we arrive:
- A photo ID that matches the address, because we verify ownership before we rekey or replace a lock on any home.
- Every working key you still have, so we can check which locks share a key today.
- A count of the exterior doors, gates and any detached storage you want on the same key.
- For a condo or rental, the written permission from your association, landlord or housing office.
Kama'aina Locksmith has been bonded and insured since 2012, is rated 4.9 stars from 1,100+ Google reviews, and is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Hawaii does not issue a state locksmith license, so proof of insurance is the credential to ask any locksmith for. For a full picture of home lock work, from deadbolts to residential locksmith upgrades, call (808) 202-3257 and tell us which doors are giving you trouble.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can all my doors be rekeyed to one key?
Often, yes. Locks from the same brand and keyway can be pinned to a single key in one visit. When a house mixes brands, some cylinders cannot share a key, so we swap the odd cylinder for a matching one and then key everything alike. Bring every current key to the appointment so we can see which doors already match.
Do I need to rekey after buying a home in Honolulu?
It is a sensible first step. Previous owners, agents, contractors and cleaners may all hold copies, and you have no way to count them. A rekey on closing day gives you a fresh set of keys without changing the hardware you just inspected. If any lock sticks or shows corrosion during that visit, that is the time to replace it.
Is rekeying as secure as a new lock?
Rekeying is as secure as the lock it is done on. New pins stop old keys just as well as a new lock does, but a rekey cannot improve a short bolt, a thin strike plate or a low-grade cylinder. If the hardware is solid, a rekey leaves you as protected as a replacement. If the hardware is weak, replacing is the real upgrade.
Can a corroded lock be rekeyed?
Sometimes, but it is rarely worth it. If the cylinder comes out and the pins and springs are still clean, a rekey works. If the plug is stiff, the springs are pitted or the key already sticks, new pins will not fix the wear. On Oahu's coast we usually recommend a cylinder swap or a full replacement in a finish made for salt air.
Should I rekey or replace after a break-in?
Replace any lock that was forced, drilled or kicked, even if it still turns, because the internal parts and the strike may be bent. Rekey the untouched doors so a key taken during the break-in no longer works. Check the frame and strike plate on the damaged door; a longer bolt and reinforced strike often matter more than the lock brand.
Need Help? Call a Local Locksmith
Kama'aina Locksmith: bonded & insured since 2012, with a typical 20-30 min response across Oahu.
Call (808) 202-3257